Yellowstone could have had a different Western movie icon playing John Dutton, which would have resulted in the show ending much sooner. Kevin Costner, who has had a successful career in a variety of genres, is closely associated with Westerns. His breakthrough role was in Silverado in 1985, and he later directed and starred in the acclaimed Dances with Wolves. Costner's upcoming movie series, Horizon: An American Saga, is also highly anticipated. However, his biggest success in recent years has been Yellowstone, where he portrays the patriarch John Dutton.
However, Costner was ultimately the best choice for the role of John Dutton. He brought a warmth and a darker edge to the character, portraying him as a man of principles with a code of honor who would do anything to protect his ranch and land. Costner's commitment to the role allowed audiences to see the character evolve over the course of the series. Despite Costner's exit and the behind-the-scenes tension, Yellowstone is set to resume production for the second part of season 5. However, reports suggest that Costner won't be involved, and he may even take legal action against Paramount over money owed to him for the series.
It would be strange for the show to conclude without Costner's appearance, especially since his final scene was a clear tease for the next season. Hopefully, Costner and Sheridan can come to a compromise and give Dutton's story a dignified ending. In conclusion, Kevin Costner's portrayal of John Dutton has been integral to Yellowstone's success. While Robert Redford almost played the role, Costner proved to be the best casting choice. However, his departure from the show under tense circumstances raises questions about the future of Yellowstone. Fans hope that Costner and Sheridan can resolve their differences and give the beloved character of John Dutton a proper send-off.