Supernatural graced our screens for fifteen incredible seasons, captivating audiences with its gripping storyline, diverse cast of monsters, and heart-wrenching plotlines. Yet, amidst all the chaos and unimaginable horrors, one crucial aspect of the show remained unwavering - the Winchester brothers themselves. Sam and Dean Winchester, unstoppable hunters of demons, found themselves trapped in a never-ending cycle of repeating their past mistakes, and this ultimately became the show's biggest downfall.
At the beginning, Supernatural embraced a procedural format, with the Winchesters tackling a new case in each episode. The monster of the week became the show's core identity, instilling a sense of familiarity in viewers. However, as the series progressed, it delved into larger, overarching storylines, placing the procedural aspect on the backburner.
The problem lay in Sam and Dean's unrelenting character archetypes. Dean, the stoic and macho brother, dutifully followed orders, while Sam, the empathetic dreamer, yearned for a life beyond hunting. Although these archetypes effectively established their identities, they also hindered their development. Throughout the show, they clung stubbornly to their predefined roles, rarely budging from their predetermined opinions and choices.
Their static nature not only stifled individual growth but also stagnated their relationship.
The decision to confine Sam and Dean within their archetypal boxes ultimately tainted the quality of Supernatural. Although the Winchesters were undoubtedly lovable characters, their lack of personal evolution prevented viewers from witnessing their maturation beyond their early twenties. This stasis and repetition persisted until the show's bittersweet conclusion.
It's difficult not to wonder what might have been if the show allowed the Winchesters room to blossom into different individuals. An opportunity for character growth could have steered Supernatural in a fresh and exciting direction, enriching the narratives and reinvigorating the passionate fanbase.
Ultimately, Supernatural will forever remain a monument to the supernatural genre, though its missed opportunity to explore the transformative journey of its central characters remains a lingering regret.